It's hard not to include Sam among my favorite icons. I have a whole section of icons labeled "Bro" so techincally this one should be there, but Dean has the sharper focus here so I'm running with that. This is such an old-school cap, but it's just as true as it ever way. "Stay with me" is what Dean desperately needs Sam to do. By seanarenay.
Shut up. Dean with a baby kills me! By bittersweet_art
LOL Sam gets all the bitchface kudos...but Dean has one too! By maharet83
He's so freakin' pretty. By dev_earl
Another season 1 cap. I think this one's been in my userpics since then. Dude is something I say all the time and this is my go-to. By neversince
Faith is one of my ALL TIME favorite episodes. I love the image of Roy's hand and how vulnerable Dean is. By navras_rheya
This is another season 1 go-to icon because Dean + fire = HOT. By nadiafox
I love that this icon ties Dean into the Wayward Son scenario. It's just a perfect combination of image and lyric. By crazypandabear
OMG the YED as John is tooclosetoDean. Another fav from season 1 that still has so much power. By eleinebrune
Who knew all my favorite icons were from season 1? I love the cropping and text on this one. I don't know who made this icon.
You can never go wrong with sleepy!Dean. By stormofdesigns.
Let's see what your favorites are!